Breach of Fiduciary Duty Lawyer in Greensboro, NC
Fiduciary cases turn on documents: bank statements, operating agreements, minutes, emails. The person you suspect usually controls those documents. The sooner a lawyer asks for them in writing, the less time there is for them to disappear.
Tell us what happened
Sending this form does not make us your lawyer yet.
A partner, LLC manager, director or officer who uses the business for their own benefit can be made to account for it. North Carolina statutes set the standard they are held to. If you think it is happening in your company, call (336) 379-0539 before the records change hands.
- What a Breach of Fiduciary Duty Looks Like in a Business
- Who Owes a Fiduciary Duty Under North Carolina Statutes
- How We Approach a Fiduciary Duty Case
- Suing for the Company: The 90-Day Demand
- How Long You Have to Act
- North Carolina Business Court
- What a Business Litigation Lawyer Costs
- How to Choose a Fiduciary Duty Lawyer in Greensboro
- Related Business Disputes
- Our team
- What clients say
- Where we practice
- Questions people ask
What a Breach of Fiduciary Duty Looks Like in a Business
A fiduciary is someone trusted to act for the business rather than for themselves. In a company, that usually means the people who run it.
Common situations we see described by business owners include:
- A manager or partner paying personal expenses from the company account.
- An owner steering a customer, contract or opportunity to a side business they own.
- A director approving a deal that benefits them personally without telling the other owners.
- A co-owner refusing to share financial records while distributions dry up.
- A partner keeping profits from a transaction connected to the partnership.
Each of these may or may not be a breach. That depends on the governing documents, what was disclosed, and which statute applies to your type of business.
Who Owes a Fiduciary Duty Under North Carolina Statutes
| Who | Standard the Statute Sets | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Corporate Director | Act in good faith, with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use, and in a manner reasonably believed to be in the corporation’s best interests | G.S. 55-8-30(a) |
| Corporate Officer | The same three standards, for officers with discretionary authority | G.S. 55-8-42(a) |
| LLC Manager | Good faith, ordinary prudent care, and, subject to the operating agreement, the LLC’s best interests | G.S. 57D-3-21(b) |
| General Partner | Must account to the partnership for any benefit, and hold as trustee any profits made without the other partners’ consent from partnership business or property | G.S. 59-51(a) |
Two details in these statutes matter in almost every case.
Reliance can be a defense. Directors, officers and managers are generally entitled to rely on reports from employees, accountants and lawyers they reasonably believe are reliable. That protection is lost if they actually knew the information was wrong (G.S. 55-8-30(b)-(c), 57D-3-21(b)).
For an LLC, the operating agreement shapes the duty. G.S. 57D-3-21 makes the manager’s “best interests” duty subject to the operating agreement. So the first thing a lawyer reads is that agreement, not the statute.
How We Approach a Fiduciary Duty Case
Our lawyers handle these cases from both sides. Some clients believe they have been wronged; others have been accused and need to defend their decisions.
When you call, we work through four questions:
- What kind of entity is it, and what do its governing documents say? Operating agreements, bylaws and partnership agreements often change the default rules.
- What records can you get now? LLC members have statutory information rights under G.S. 57D-3-04, including tax returns or financial statements for the preceding four fiscal years. Partners have a right to a formal account in the situations listed in G.S. 59-52.
- Is the claim yours, or the company’s? If the harm was to the business, the claim usually belongs to the business. That changes who can sue and what must happen first.
- What is the clock? Limitations periods run whether or not you are still negotiating.
From there the options include a demand letter, negotiated buyout, mediation, an accounting action, or a lawsuit.
A strong written record built early is what gives the negotiation weight. That record is what your lawyer is for.
Suing for the Company: The 90-Day Demand
When the injury is to the corporation or LLC rather than to you personally, the lawsuit is usually a derivative action, brought in the company’s name.
North Carolina requires a written demand first:
| Entity | What the Statute Requires Before Suing | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Corporation | A written demand delivered to the corporation describing the reasons and the action requested, then 90 days unless the demand is rejected sooner or waiting would cause irreparable injury | G.S. 55-7-42 |
| LLC | The member must have been a member at the time of the act, made a written demand, and either had it rejected, waited 90 days, or show irreparable injury from waiting | G.S. 57D-8-01(a) |
A poorly drafted demand can create problems later. A lawyer drafts it so it describes the reasons “in reasonable detail”, which is the phrase G.S. 55-7-42 uses, and so it preserves your position if the company refuses.
How Long You Have to Act
G.S. 1-52 sets a three-year period for many claims, including actions on a contract (1-52(1)) and on a liability created by statute (1-52(2)).
For claims based on fraud, G.S. 1-52(9) says the claim does not accrue until the facts are discovered.
Which limitations period applies to a particular fiduciary claim is often argued. Do not assume you have three years from today; call and have it checked against your facts.
North Carolina Business Court
Any party may designate a case as a mandatory complex business case when it involves a material issue about the law governing corporations, partnerships or LLCs, including disputes under Chapters 55, 57D and 59 (G.S. 7A-45.4(a)(1)).
That sends the case to the North Carolina Business Court. Whether designation helps your side is a strategic decision, and it is made early.
What a Business Litigation Lawyer Costs
Fees depend on whether the case resolves by letter, negotiation or litigation, and on how many records must be reviewed.
We explain the fee structure at the first meeting and put it in writing before work starts.
How to Choose a Fiduciary Duty Lawyer in Greensboro
North Carolina’s professional conduct rules do not allow a firm to call itself the best. Ask any firm you are considering:
- Have you handled disputes under Chapter 55, 57D or 59 in Superior Court or the Business Court?
- Will you read the operating agreement or bylaws before advising me?
- Do you represent both claimants and accused managers, and how do you check for conflicts?
- How will you get the financial records, and how soon?
- What will the first phase cost, and what triggers the next phase?
Related Business Disputes
Fiduciary claims often travel with other claims. See our pages on partnership and LLC member disputes, unfair competition, breach of contract and business litigation.
Many of these disputes start with vague governing documents. If you are still forming the business, that is the cheapest place to prevent one.
Our team
Chad D. GarrettFounder
Jason AycothPartner
Sean OlsonPartner
Brandon GoldsboroughCriminal Defense
Stephanie GoldsboroughCriminal Defense
Rebecca ElliottCriminal Defense
Patrick BidwellCriminal Defense
Samantha HeplerCriminal DefenseWhat clients say
4.9 out of 5 from 587 Google reviews. A few recent ones:
Where we practice
Guilford County: Greensboro · High Point · Jamestown · Gibsonville · Summerfield · Oak Ridge · Pleasant Garden · Stokesdale · Whitsett · McLeansville · Sedalia
Also serving: Randolph, Forsyth, Alamance, Rockingham and Davidson Counties
Questions people ask
What is a breach of fiduciary duty in a North Carolina business?
It is a failure by someone who must act for the business, such as a director, officer, LLC manager or partner, to meet the standard the law sets. For directors that standard is good faith, ordinary prudent care and acting in the corporation’s best interests, under G.S. 55-8-30.
Do LLC managers owe fiduciary duties in North Carolina?
Yes. G.S. 57D-3-21(b) requires managers to act in good faith, with ordinary prudent care, and, subject to the operating agreement, in the LLC’s best interests. The operating agreement can shape what that means.
Do business partners owe each other fiduciary duties?
A general partner must account to the partnership for any benefit and hold as trustee any profits made without the other partners’ consent from partnership business or property, under G.S. 59-51.
Can I sue a co-owner personally?
Sometimes. If the harm was to the company, the claim usually belongs to the company and must be brought as a derivative action after a written demand. A lawyer sorts out which claims are yours and which are the company’s.
What is a derivative lawsuit?
A suit brought by an owner in the right of the corporation or LLC to recover for an injury to it. North Carolina requires a written demand first and, in most cases, a 90-day wait, under G.S. 55-7-42 and 57D-8-01.
How long do I have to file a fiduciary duty claim?
Many claims carry a three-year period under G.S. 1-52, and fraud claims run from discovery under 1-52(9). Which period applies is often contested, so have it checked early.
Can I see the company’s financial records?
LLC members can inspect tax returns or financial statements for the preceding four fiscal years and other records under G.S. 57D-3-04. Partners have a right to a formal account in the situations in G.S. 59-52.
Can a director rely on the accountant and still be liable?
A director can generally rely on reports from accountants and other advisers they reasonably believe are competent. That protection does not apply if the director actually knew the information was wrong, under G.S. 55-8-30(c).
Will my case go to the Business Court?
It may. A party can designate a case involving the law of corporations, partnerships or LLCs as a mandatory complex business case under G.S. 7A-45.4.
Do you defend people accused of breaching fiduciary duty?
Yes. We represent both business owners bringing claims and managers, officers and partners defending them, subject to a conflict check.
Talk to a lawyer today
Garrett, Walker, Aycoth & Olson, Attorneys at Law
317 South Greene St, Greensboro, NC 27401
(336) 379-0539 · answered live, 24 hours
Free consultation · Se habla español
This page provides general information about North Carolina law, including G.S. 1-52, 7A-45.4, 55-7-40.1, 55-7-42, 55-8-30, 55-8-42, 57D-3-04, 57D-3-21, 57D-8-01, 59-51 and 59-52. It is not legal advice.
